When you read in a memoir: “It is perhaps necessary to say that the following narrative, in all its parts, and so far as the punctilious attention of the writer has been able to keep it so, is scrupulously true” do you believe it?

I was certainly disposed to do so when reading Father and Son (Ca 12741) by Edmund Gosse (1849-1928). The book is a Penguin Twentieth Century Classic, has never been out of print since first publication in 1907 and the writer was a pillar of the literary establishment. A librarian, no less, in both the British Museum and the House of Lords, Gosse was also employed as a lecturer at Cambridge and as a translator by the Board of Trade. He was knighted in 1925. Cast iron credentials.

The memoir is beguilingly and compulsively readable.  Subtitled A Study of Two Temperaments, it tells how Edmund endured a suffocating childhood in a Puritan household before leaving home for London and finding emancipation in his first job, with the British Museum. The story is of Edmund’s inner growth and his eventual assertion of the right to be different to his father’s expectations for him. As readers, we find ourselves firmly on the side of the son in his spiritual struggle.

Edmund’s father was a naturalist who travelled widely and published many works, including  A History of British Sea Anemones and Corals and The Romance of Natural History. His consuming passion, however, was the Bible, which he learned by heart and preached in the village “Room” in St. Marychurch, near Torquay, to where he moved after his first wife’s death, when Edmund was six. His wife had been a writer of religious verse and was as dedicated as her husband to making their son the “Charles Wesley of his age.” From his earliest years Edmund believed he was destined for the religious life.

However, when ten or eleven he began to be influenced by things other than his father’s dogmatic theology. The first was poetry, particularly Virgil, which awoke in him “the amazing beauty that could exist in the sound of verses.” He developed a fascination with words and earned his father’s disapproval for spending hours reading a dictionary. He was given an adventure novel, Tom Cringle’s

Log, set in the Caribbean, his first taste of fiction, which he read and re-read. “This did more than anything else, in this critical eleventh year of my life, to give fortitude to my individuality.”

Later, he met by chance an elderly Baptist minister, who had once been a playwright, who introduced him to Shakespeare. His teacher agreed to readings at school of The Merchant of Venice but they were short-lived; Gosse suspected his father’s intervention. “He prided himself on never having read a word of Shakespeare and on never having entered a theatre but once.” His new stepmother was less puritanical than his mother had been and supported Edmund in his request to be allowed to read Sir Walter Scott’s Waverley Novels. His father refused, as “those tales gave false and disturbing pictures of life.” Curiously, he was happy about the young Gosse reading Dickens and his stepmother obtained a copy of The Pickwick Papers, which gave him months of rapture.

Christopher Marlowe fared less well, however, and Edmund was denounced by his father for bringing an “abominable” book of verses (he objected in particular to Hero and Leander) into the house. It was promptly burned. Things came to a head shortly after his move to London, when, on a trip back to Devon, his father quizzed him on whether he was “walking closely with God,” and whether “his sense of the efficacy of the Atonement was clear and sound.”  In the Epilogue to the memoir, Gosse says he replied violently and hysterically, demanding the right to think for himself. There was from that point, at the age of twenty-one, no common ground with his father, no hope of a compromise.

That is, if all this is “scrupulously true.” Ann Thwaite, in her fascinating book Glimpses of the Wonderful: The Life of Philip Henry Gosse (Ca 12450), believes it is not. Gosse’s father, Philip Henry (Edmund doesn’t tell us his name) lived another twenty years after Edmund left home and there is evidence that the relationship did not break down. The father came to accept, although he regretted, his son’s different position on religion to his own, was devoted to his son’s new wife and was a benign grandfather to their children. After a visit to his father, Edmund wrote to his wife that his father was “extremely hearty and in high spirits; his whole heart and time are given up to the butterflies; it seems the butterflies a little cast out the religion.”  Thwaite even finds evidence that Philip Henry read and quoted Shakespeare all his life, quoting him in his memoirs. She says that mutual reproaches ceased and the mutual love of father and son remained.

Some years before writing Father and Son, Edmund had written a biography of his father, who died in 1888. It seems his friend, George Moore, suggested that he should re-write it, focusing on the conflict between the father and the son, using the first person and relying on memory rather than the factual record. In taking this advice, Edmund Gosse wrote a brilliant narrative but made himself an unreliable witness about his father’s character and the details of their relationship. Ann Thwaite’s book more than restores the balance.

Both books can be found in the Ellen Harrington Room.

A review by Library member Martin Gorman